Hotels in Shelter Island
One price for everyone — never based on your data.
3 stays · loading prices…
The Pridwin Hotel
Shelter Island, New York
SpaParking
9.1Exceptional · 143 reviews
Checking price…
Sunset Beach Hotel
Shelter Island, New York
EV chargingFree WiFi
9.2Exceptional · 11 reviews
Checking price…
Rams Head Inn
Shelter Island, New York
ParkingAir conditioning
5.6OK · 5 reviews
Checking price…
That's all 3 stays.