Open Hearth Lodge
2669 S Bay Shore Drive, Sister Bay, Wisconsin, 54234, Sister Bay
Checking price…
Top-rated location
Guests rate location 10.0/10.
Guest favorite
Exceptional reviews from recent guests.
Pool on site
Cool off without leaving.
Guests loved it
Friendly staff
Popular amenities
About Open Hearth Lodge
Indoor Pool, Spa Tub, and Sauna
Enjoy the relaxation and rejuvenation with our indoor pool, spa tub, and sauna.
Complimentary Breakfast and Amenities
Start your day right with our daily complimentary continental breakfast. Plus, take advantage of our computer station, luggage storage, and laundry facilities.
Comfortable Rooms with Free Wi-Fi
Unwind in our air-conditioned rooms with free Wi-Fi and cable programming. Feel at home with amenities like refrigerators, desks, and daily housekeeping.
Experience comfort and convenience at Open Hearth Lodge. Book your stay now for a relaxing getaway near the beach.
Good to know about Open Hearth Lodge
Check-in
03:30 PM
Check-out
11:00 AM
Pets
Not allowed
Children
Adults only
How Open Hearth Lodge's price works
One flat fee
The price is what the hotel charges us plus one small, flat service fee — the same for every guest.
No surveillance pricing
We never use your device, location or browsing history to decide what you pay.
All-in, no surprises
Taxes and known fees are shown up front. What you see is what you book.
Open Hearth Lodge reviews
Exceptional
171 reviews · updated January 2026
Guests loved
- + Friendly staff
- + Good location
- + Clean facilities
- + Dog-friendly
Worth noting
- – Limited breakfast options
- – Some rooms reported dampness
- – Initial check-in issues
Things to do near Open Hearth Lodge
2669 S Bay Shore Drive, Sister Bay, Wisconsin, 54234, Sister Bay
Open in Google Maps ↗Open Hearth Lodge property amenities
Internet
- Free WiFi
Parking & transportation
- Wheelchair accessible parking
- Free self parking
- Wheelchair-accessible van parking
Pools, spa & fitness
- Fitness facilities
- Health or beauty spa nearby
- Sauna
- Pool sun loungers
Food & drink
- Free breakfast
- Continental breakfast
- Free continental breakfast
Family
- Playground on site
- Children's games
- Children's toys
Things to do
- Terrace
- Garden
- Golfing nearby
Services & conveniences
- Luggage storage
- Elevator
- Front desk (limited hours)
- Coin laundry on site
Climate & comfort
- Designated smoking area
More
- Boat tours nearby
- Parasailing nearby
- Firepit
- Fireplace in lobby
- Picnic area
- Cross-country skiing nearby
- Hiking/biking trails nearby
- Kayaking nearby
- Sailing nearby
- Television in common areas
- Computer station
Open Hearth Lodge room amenities
Bedroom
- No rollaway/extra beds
- No cribs (infant beds)
- Bedsheets provided
- Sofa bed
Bathroom
- Hair dryer
- Private bathroom
- Jetted bathtub
Entertainment
- TV
- Closed captioned TV
Food & drink
- Kitchenette
- Refrigerator
- Kitchen
Internet & phone
- Free WiFi
- Telephone
Comfort
- Air conditioning
More
- Desk
- Interconnected room(s) available
- Daily housekeeping
- Fireplace
- Wheelchair accessible
Frequently asked questions about Open Hearth Lodge
What are the check-in and check-out times at Open Hearth Lodge?
Check-in starts at 03:30 PM and check-out is by 11:00 AM.
Does Open Hearth Lodge have WiFi?
WiFi is available at Open Hearth Lodge. Check your room's details for whether it's free or carries a charge.
Is parking available at Open Hearth Lodge?
Yes, parking is available at Open Hearth Lodge. A fee may apply — see the property's important information.
Does Open Hearth Lodge serve breakfast?
Yes, breakfast is available at Open Hearth Lodge. A fee may apply unless your rate includes it.
Does Open Hearth Lodge have a pool?
Yes — Open Hearth Lodge has a swimming pool.
Does Open Hearth Lodge have a spa?
Yes, Open Hearth Lodge offers spa or wellness facilities.
Is there a gym at Open Hearth Lodge?
Yes, Open Hearth Lodge has fitness facilities.
Is Open Hearth Lodge wheelchair accessible?
Open Hearth Lodge offers facilities for guests with disabilities. Contact the property to confirm the specifics for your needs.
Is Open Hearth Lodge pet-friendly?
No, pets are not allowed at Open Hearth Lodge.
Is Open Hearth Lodge family-friendly?
Yes, Open Hearth Lodge welcomes families and offers family facilities.
How far is Open Hearth Lodge from Honolulu airport (HNL)?
It's about 4263 mi (straight-line) from Honolulu airport (HNL).
What's the closest beach to Open Hearth Lodge?
The nearest is Lanikai Beach, about 4250 mi away (straight-line).
What is the cancellation policy at Open Hearth Lodge?
It depends on the rate you pick — many rooms at Open Hearth Lodge offer free cancellation. You'll see each room's exact policy before you book.
Are there extra fees at Open Hearth Lodge?
Any mandatory property fees are shown in your all-in total before you book — no surprises at checkout.
What guest services does Open Hearth Lodge offer?
Open Hearth Lodge offers services such as laundry, luggage storage.
Is Open Hearth Lodge a good place to stay?
Guests rate it 9.6/10 (Exceptional) across 171 reviews.
How does pricing work at Open Hearth Lodge on travelpluscost?
One honest price: what the hotel charges us plus one small flat fee — the same for everyone, never based on your data. No hidden markup and no fake discounts.
Open Hearth Lodge policies
Pets
Service animals are exempt from fees/restrictions
General
Professional property host/manager
Pets
Service animals are allowed
You need to know about Open Hearth Lodge
The property has connecting/adjoining rooms, which are subject to availability and can be requested by contacting the property using the number on the booking confirmation.
More hotels in Sister Bay
The Nordic Lodge
Sister Bay
Sister Bay Inn
Sister Bay
Coachlite Inn
Sister Bay
Country House Resort
Sister Bay
The Inn at Little Sister Hill
Sister Bay
Scandinavian Lodge
Sister Bay
Birchwood Lodge
Sister Bay
Pheasant Park Resort
Sister Bay
Goose & Twigs
Sister Bay
DownTown Inn
Sister Bay
The Liberty Lodge at Sister Bay
Sister Bay