Hotels in Shelter Island, NY
Check prices for these dates
Showing 3 of 3 stays
The Pridwin Hotel
Shelter Island, New York
SpaParking
Sunset Beach Hotel
Shelter Island, New York
EV chargingFree WiFi
Rams Head Inn
Shelter Island, New York
ParkingAir conditioning
Why Shelter Island hotels cost less here
Most travel sites quietly mark up your room — and some change the price based on your device, location or browsing history. We don't. You pay what the hotel charges us plus one small flat fee, and it's the same number for every traveler on every screen. No surveillance pricing. Ever.
Hotels in Shelter Island: common questions
How many hotels are in Shelter Island?
There are 3 hotels in Shelter Island, NY on travelpluscost. The highest-rated right now is The Pridwin Hotel, with a 9.1/10 guest score from 143 reviews.
How does travelpluscost keep Shelter Island hotels cheaper?
You pay what the hotel charges us plus one small flat fee — the same price for every traveler, on every device. We never raise the price based on your location, browser or history. That flat fee is usually less than the hidden markup most travel sites bake in.
Are taxes and resort fees included in the price?
Yes. Every room shows the all-in price — the nightly rate plus taxes and known fees — so the total you see is the total you pay. Where a Shelter Island hotel charges a resort or property fee, it's already in that number.
Can I cancel a Shelter Island hotel booking?
Many Shelter Island hotels offer fully refundable rates. When a room can be cancelled for free we label it "Fully refundable", so you can spot a flexible rate at a glance.
All 3 hotels in Shelter Island
Every stay we cover here — pick any to see live prices.