Athenaeum Hotel
3 S Lake Dr, Mayville, New York, 14757, Mayville
Checking price…
Popular amenities
About Athenaeum Hotel
Stunning Garden Views
Enjoy the picturesque garden views surrounding Athenaeum Hotel. Stay connected with complimentary wireless internet and take advantage of concierge services during your stay.
Delicious Dining and Lounge
Indulge in a satisfying meal at Heirloom restaurant or unwind with a drink at the bar/lounge. A perfect way to end your day at our hotel.
Convenient Amenities and Meeting Spaces
Benefit from amenities like a 24-hour front desk, luggage storage, and safety deposit boxes. Our hotel also offers 2 meeting rooms for your events.
Located steps away from Chautauqua Amphitheater and Chautauqua Lake, Athenaeum Hotel in Chautauqua provides a perfect retreat. Book your stay with us now to experience a blend of comfort and convenience.
Good to know about Athenaeum Hotel
Check-in
03:00 PM
Check-out
10:00 AM
Pets
Allowed
Children
Adults only
How Athenaeum Hotel's price works
One flat fee
The price is what the hotel charges us plus one small, flat service fee — the same for every guest.
No surveillance pricing
We never use your device, location or browsing history to decide what you pay.
All-in, no surprises
Taxes and known fees are shown up front. What you see is what you book.
Athenaeum Hotel reviews
Very good
129 reviews · updated January 2026
Guests loved
- + Charming atmosphere
- + Accommodating staff
Worth noting
- – Limited food options
- – Parking inconvenience
Things to do near Athenaeum Hotel
3 S Lake Dr, Mayville, New York, 14757, Mayville
Open in Google Maps ↗Athenaeum Hotel property amenities
Internet
- Free WiFi
Parking & transportation
- Wheelchair accessible parking
- Free self parking
- Wheelchair-accessible van parking
- Valet for wheelchair-equipped vehicle
Food & drink
- Wheelchair-accessible on-site restaurant
Accessibility
- Wheelchair-accessible public washroom
Things to do
- Garden
Services & conveniences
- 24-hour front desk
- Luggage storage
- Concierge service
- Elevator
- Safe-deposit box at front desk
More
- Fireplace in lobby
- Television in common areas
- Smoke-free property
- Handrails in stairways
- Well-lit path to entrance
- Stair-free path to entrance
Athenaeum Hotel room amenities
Bedroom
- Free cribs/infant beds
- Bedsheets provided
Bathroom
- Bathrobe
- Slippers
Entertainment
- TV
Internet & phone
- Telephone
- Free Local calls
- Free WiFi
Comfort
- Air conditioning
More
- Wheelchair accessible
- Daily housekeeping
- Local maps
Frequently asked questions about Athenaeum Hotel
What are the check-in and check-out times at Athenaeum Hotel?
Check-in starts at 03:00 PM and check-out is by 10:00 AM.
Does Athenaeum Hotel have WiFi?
WiFi is available at Athenaeum Hotel. Check your room's details for whether it's free or carries a charge.
Is parking available at Athenaeum Hotel?
Yes, parking is available at Athenaeum Hotel, including valet. A fee may apply — see the property's important information.
Does Athenaeum Hotel have a restaurant?
Yes, there is on-site dining at Athenaeum Hotel.
Is Athenaeum Hotel wheelchair accessible?
Athenaeum Hotel offers facilities for guests with disabilities. Contact the property to confirm the specifics for your needs.
Is Athenaeum Hotel pet-friendly?
Yes, pets are allowed at Athenaeum Hotel.
How far is Athenaeum Hotel from Honolulu airport (HNL)?
It's about 4666 mi (straight-line) from Honolulu airport (HNL).
What's the closest beach to Athenaeum Hotel?
The nearest is Lanikai Beach, about 4652 mi away (straight-line).
What is the cancellation policy at Athenaeum Hotel?
It depends on the rate you pick — many rooms at Athenaeum Hotel offer free cancellation. You'll see each room's exact policy before you book.
Are there extra fees at Athenaeum Hotel?
Any mandatory property fees are shown in your all-in total before you book — no surprises at checkout.
What guest services does Athenaeum Hotel offer?
Athenaeum Hotel offers services such as concierge, luggage storage.
Is Athenaeum Hotel a good place to stay?
Guests rate it 8.4/10 (Very good) across 129 reviews.
How does pricing work at Athenaeum Hotel on travelpluscost?
One honest price: what the hotel charges us plus one small flat fee — the same for everyone, never based on your data. No hidden markup and no fake discounts.
Athenaeum Hotel policies
Sustainability Certifications
Property confirms they are implementing guest safety measures
Pets
Service animals are exempt from fees/restrictions
General
Individually-wrapped food options are available for breakfast
Check-in & Check-out
Contactless check-out is available
General
Gloves are available to guests
General
Guests are provided with free hand sanitizer
General
Masks are available to guests
Guest type
Essential workers only - NO
General
Individually-wrapped food options are available
General
Bed sheets and towels are washed at a temperature of at least 60°C/140°F
General
Staff wears personal protective equipment
Pets
Pets allowed
General
Property is cleaned with disinfectant
General
Social distancing measures are in place
General
Professional property host/manager
General
Protective clothing is available to guests
General
Property follows sanitization practices of SafeStay (AHLA - USA)
Sustainability Certifications
Property confirms they are implementing enhanced cleaning measures
General
Commonly-touched surfaces are cleaned with disinfectant
Pets
Only dogs are allowed
Pets
Service animals are allowed
You need to know about Athenaeum Hotel
Contactless check-out is available.
Explore Mayville, New York
See all hotels in Mayville →More destinations in New York